Rob from Love Island USA? Lisa Rinna? Johnny Weir? Are these celebrities on Cameo, or are they the upcoming cast of The Traitors US season four? There is no official casting announcement made by Peacock nor Alan Cumming, so why is everyone talking about the new season? Season four is reportedly set to start filming this summer, and a cast list has begun circulating online, featuring a few plausible faithfuls and traitors. However, the internet already has a fan favorite in mind: Donna Kelce, Travis and Jason Kelce’s mother. She just posted getting a fresh manicure a week ago, maybe she was prepping to go to Scotland? The New Heights TikTok account just shared a video of the brothers talking about The Traitors with the caption, “Reposting this for no reason whatsoever.” Suspicious!

Other names being rumored include Real Housewives’s Dorinda Medley, who was one of the first to get eliminated last season, Drag Race’s Monet X Change, and Bachelor Nation’s Colton Underwood. Again, none of these names are confirmed by Peacock. But then again, Rob was just seen in Italy, just a short flight away from the Traitors castle…

Related

• The Traitors Has a Glaring Flaw When It Comes to the Actual Game
• The Best TV Shows of 2025 (So Far)
• Cast Elon Musk’s Estranged Daughter on The Traitors
• Who Should Be in the Traitors 4 Cast?

 Mama Kelce, why are you (allegedly) in Scotland?